The Naples Design Review Board has approved a revised plan to upgrade and expand the popular HB’s on the Gulf restaurant.
The board voted 4-1 in favor of the scheme on Wednesday, paving the way for permitting.
The new architectural design includes the addition of a private dining room that will offer a chef’s table experience.
The experience would allow diners to get up close and personal with the chef and enjoy a more memorable interactive meal, explained Tim McCarthy, a project architect with Hart Howerton in New York.
The board applauded the more immersive dining approach.
“I’ve not seen that,” said member Lindsey Bulloch.
Other tweaks include moving a chimney and adding a fabric awning to the roofline and to provide more shading across the western edge of the waterfront restaurant, steps away from the Gulf of Mexico.
“We moved away from a solid roof,” McCarthy said.
The awning replicates ones from HB’s early days, harkening to its legacy of warm hospitality in Naples — with an old Florida feel.
Opportunities to improve the renovation plans
The Design Review Board approved plans for a rebuild of HB’s and the neighboring Sunset Beach Bar more than a year ago, presented by its previous longtime owners, the Watkins family.
The new owners and developers of the property, The Athens Group, supported that plan, but saw opportunities to improve upon it, McCarthy said.
The developer faced a few hiccups and hurdles before getting back to the Design Review Board.
With its revised plan approved, the developer can now apply for building permits to start the renovations. That right had expired, under the initial plan proposed by the Watkinses.
From the get-go, The Athens Group has promised to ensure HB’s and the Sunset Beach Bar and their traditions remain a focal point of its upscale resort development known as Naples Beach Club.
The resort project will feature luxury condos and a Four Seasons Resort on a 125-acre site, including the existing 18-hole golf course and a new Market Square.
The new development will replace the landmark Naples Beach Hotel, owned and operated by the Watkins family for more than 70 years.
While it took longer than expected, The Athens Group can carry out the renovations in the safest and smartest way possible now, taking advantage of the latest building codes and science in Florida, McCarthy said.
That’s because during the delay the developer secured a change in the property’s flood zone designation by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, he said, which will allow for the use of better construction technology, including dry floodproofing.
Importantly, McCarthy said, the “toes-in-the-sand” feel will not be lost.
The plan is to expand HB’s by 3,500 square feet, while preserving its views and unassuming, coastal building style, including its metal roof.
Design Review Board, public weighs in on improvements to HB’s
Board member Luke Fredrickson liked the latest changes.
“It’s fun to see the evolution come together and see talented architectural firms deal with these issues and make changes in my opinion that actually improve the design of the project,” he said.
Others agreed.
Several board members felt the improvements to HB’s could have been even better, considering the caliber of its architects and the big financial commitment by the developer and its investors. They suggested there could have been lusher landscaping and vaster shading, setting a new bar for others to follow in Naples.
While she clearly liked some of the new features, member Adriane Orion shot down the final plan, saying it wasn’t climate-responsive and sorely lacked the required energy-efficient architectural and design features to reduce its impact on the natural environment.
“Absolutely not. No,” she said in casting her lone no vote.
Naples resident Miranda Sharkey spoke in favor of the planned improvements to HB’s and the Sunset Beach Bar, encouraging the Design Review Board to move them along.
HB’s, she said, holds a special place not only in her heart, but in the hearts of her family and friends, who’ve shared special moments there, enjoying its delicious food and friendly, customer-focused atmosphere, while taking in its beautiful sunsets.
She looks forward to the opening of the much-improved restaurant and bar.
“The community will be grateful for this gift,” Sharkey said. “I know I am, and my family.”
Project marches on despite opposition from angry neighbor
Neighbor Greg Myers continued to voice his opposition to the planned renovations to the restaurant and bar, urging the Design Review Board not to give them the green light.
After making his brief comments, he said: “I see stares from the board. I have no faith in this board, other than a few people. And I doubt you will do the right thing.”
Myers also objected to a final landscaping scheme for a maintenance building and chiller plant on the golf course, which the Design Review Board also approved Wednesday,
Myers told the board if it didn’t do the right thing, a judge would, suggesting he might pursue a legal challenge if the votes didn’t go his way.
In his persistent attempts to stop the Naples Beach Club redevelopment project, on the whole, Myers has filed a string of suits against the city, the developers and others over the past 15 months, most of which are pending.
In May, a Collier Circuit Court dealt him a big blow in his property rights dispute, granting summary judgment in favor of the developers and current and previous owners.
Based on publicly recorded plats and easements, Myers asserted he and his wife had an interest in the resort property, so they should have more power to determine what becomes of it.
Judge Lauren Brodie found otherwise, ruling that the couple failed to present evidence “sufficient” to “sustain their claims” of any such right to influence or block the development.
Reaction to Design Review Board’s favorable votes
After Wednesday’s Design Review Board meeting, Myers shot off an email to its members and city leaders, including the mayor, expressing his disappointment with its favorable decisions.
He claimed the board approved “18,500 square feet of commercial/industrial buildings on land designated ‘public, semi-public and private recreation and open space'” in the city’s comprehensive plan, which allows for “zero density/zero intensity.”
“What a bunch of dopes,” he wrote.
Further, Myers warned that if The Athens Group “elects to move forward knowing that the zoning approvals are inconsistent with the comprehensive plan’s future land use designation, they do so at their own peril.”
He concluded his email with two words: “Fed up.”
In a reply to his email, board member Orion said: “Sir, you are rude and it is distasteful.”
Although there are disagreements, she wrote, the board and everyone else involved in the redevelopment project are “all trying to do their best for our community.”
City planners have found the planned development consistent and compatible, with no concerns about any part of it, including the upgrades to HB’s and the Sunset Beach Bar.
The Athens Group has described Myers’s lawsuits and legal and procedural challenges as baseless and “without merit.”
His motives are unclear.
In a statement, Jay Newman, the developer’s chief operating officer, said the company’s leaders are pleased with the Design Review Board’s continued support and appreciated its time and ‘thoughtful input” on Wednesday.
“We look forward to renovating HB’s and the Sunset Bar, carrying on the legacy, and returning them much improved and more beautiful than ever to the community,” he said.
Read the article in the Naples Daily News.